Blueprint: Brookfield shelves Center Parcs sale, NBIM’s first real estate outlay in 2023, APG and Bouwinvest combine for affordable housing

Brookfield shelves plans to offload Center Parcs, with Europe's hospitality investment market notably inactive; Norges Bank Investment Management's $746 million life science investment in Boston is the first for the state investor in 2023; Dutch investors APG and Bouwinvest combine to solve for their country's affordable housing challenge; and more in today's briefing, exclusively for our valued subscribers.

They said it

“There are forced sales, and there will be more of them that will also lead to interesting buying opportunities”

Margaret McKnight, partner and head of real estate portfolio solutions at StepStone Group, tells Bloomberg TV that opportunities to invest via recapitalizations are already prevalent.

What’s new?

The waterside lodges by the lake at Center Parcs

Still searching for the exit

As interest rates remain high, the wait goes on for a mega-manager to successfully make a mega-move in Europe’s hospitality sector. In a telling sign of the pricing gap that still exists between buyers and sellers in private real estate, Brookfield’s sale of Center Parcs has collapsed. The Canadian property giant, which has owned the outdoors-focused resort chain since purchasing it from Blackstone for £2.4 billion (€2.75 billion; $3.07 billion) in 2015, was aiming for a sale of more than £4 billion before abandoning plans to exit, according to the Financial Times.

The lack of many £1 billion-plus deals in the European hospitality sector this year has meant Brookfield faced a sizeable feat to shift a platform with a price tag as high as Center Parcs. The leisure platform was put up for sale in May, and reportedly drew bids from Blackstone, CVC Capital Partners, Aermont Capital, GIC and KSL Capital Partners before the auction closed with no buyer. Earlier in the year it was reported that Brookfield had opened discussions with limited partners around a possible stake sale in Center Parcs, which comprises six holiday parks across the UK and Ireland. A source close to the matter told PERE: “A full sale in the next few weeks looks unlikely now but there are ongoing discussions and Brookfield is assessing its options.”

Easing the pressure

Most institutional investors are needing to wait for the denominator effect on their portfolios to ease, or are having to sell assets to buy again. Not Norges Bank Investment Management, the steward of Norway’s $1.458 trillion sovereign wealth fund. As executives of the investor said at PERE America last week, after approving an allocation increase to real estate of up to 7 percent, it now has an additional $30 billion of equity to deploy.

The issue for NBIM, however, is finding the right acquisitions. Last week’s $746 billion commitment to approximately 810,000 square feet of life science campus space near Boston will have eased the deployment pressure, even if it was the state investor’s first real estate outlay in 2023. NBIM acquired a 45 percent interest in two properties in Cambridge, preleased entirely to pharmaceutical giant AstraZeneca, via a joint venture with mega-manager Blackstone from listed specialist Boston Properties. The deal for the assets at 290 and 300 Binney Street, valuing the venture at $1.66 billion, was conducted with no financing involved – necessary in a market devoid of credit providers.

 Alecta speaks out on Heimstaden investigation

The heat is intensifying on Swedish occupational pension provider Alecta after the country’s Financial Supervisory Authority reported “one or more people to the police” in connection to an investigation in its $4.6 billion investment in Swedish residential real estate business Heimstaden Bostad, according to a statement by the investor. Alecta said this happened after it sought two law firms for “assessments” of any potentially legal violations by the person or persons.

Alecta chairman Jan-Olof Jacke further said: “Since there were different assessments of possible violations of the law and since a police report on insufficient grounds could have negative consequence for both individuals and Alecta’s customers, the board decided not to report to the police, and handed over both investigations to the financial supervisory authority.” The investigation into Alecta’s notably large investment in Heimstaden commenced in September. It followed the firm’s rapid but debt-fuelled growth following the global financial crisis.

Trending topics

PERE America wraps

The PERE America Forum 2023 – which spanned two days and brought 150 delegates to New York last week – has now wrapped. Journalists from PERE and its affiliate titles did double duty by both moderating and reporting on the discussions between some of private real estate’s brightest minds. Here are some highlights.

In the opening sessions on real estate debt, delegates spoke about the lack of clarity around real estate values, and how even a large-scale transaction like the anticipated sale of the former Signature Bank’s $33 billion commercial real estate loan portfolio was not necessarily a game-changer. “I’ve heard people say the sale of the Signature Bank portfolio will be the catalyst for value, but that won’t really tell you anything,” said John Murray, managing director, global private real estate at California-based PIMCO. “If you’re on the outside, you don’t even know what the assets are.” Check out our coverage here.

Meanwhile, liquidity constraints were front and center in an institutional investor panel on capital allocations. Indeed, having capital to redeploy into new opportunities was a challenge many investors faced, whether or not they held control positions in their investments. Additionally, “this environment is making us think a lot harder about liquidity in the future,” said Ed Lerum, head of global logistics real estate at Norges Bank Investment Management. Click here for the full story.

In a one-on-one interview on Local Law 97, Rohit Aggarwala, commissioner of the New York City Department of Environmental Protection and chief climate officer, talked about doing the math for one of the most ambitious laws for reducing emissions in the US. While 70 percent of New York’s carbon emissions come from buildings, 50 percent of that total comes from the 5 percent of properties classified as large buildings, he noted. For more details, read the piece here.

Data snapshot

Japan Post supercharges AUM

Japan Post Bank’s real estate assets under management increased from ¥1 trillion ($6.75 billion; €6.16 billion) in 2020 to ¥4 trillion in 2023. This is part of the investor’s broader push to increase its allocation to strategic investment, including private equity funds, real estate funds, direct lending funds and infrastructure debt funds. Its strategic investment portfolio climbed from ¥3.3 trillion to ¥11.2 trillion over the same period,  according to documents from its latest investor meeting.

People

Clarion hires for alternatives

JPMorgan’s long-serving real estate executive Kimberly Adams will join New York-based manager Clarion Partners as a managing director to lead its growth in alternative property sectors. She will start the role in early 2024, working closely with the firm’s chief investment officer, Jeb Belford, according to a statement.

Prior to joining Clarion, Adams spent 20 years at JPMorgan where she was most recently a managing director for 10 years overseeing the portfolio management team for its $40 billion-plus flagship core open-end Strategic Property Fund. David Gilbert, chief executive officer at Clarion, described the expansion into alternative real estate sectors as a “key growth initiative”, with the firm seeking to provide diversified products to its investors.

Investor watch

Double Dutch impact

Dutch investors Bouwinvest and APG have formed a partnership to invest €400 million in affordable housing throughout the Netherlands. The commitments, which comprise €250 million from APG via pension fund client ABP, and €150 million from Bouwinvest via pension fund client bpfBOUW, will be directed toward the provision of rental housing for lower- and middle-income earners in the country. Housing and care-related homes will represent a minimum of 80 percent of the investment, with the remainder deployed in social real estate such as schools or community centers, according to an announcement.

The Dutch Social Impact Real Estate Partnership is the latest example of the growing appetite among investors to tie social impact objectives with supply and demand value drivers – a preference that more managers are also seeking to tap. Indeed, global data from affiliate title New Private Markets finds six funds have launched this year that are classified as impact vehicles invested solely in real estate.

This week’s investor meetings

Tuesday, November 21

Thursday, November 23

Friday, November 24


Today’s letter was prepared by Jonathan Brasse, with Evelyn Lee, Charlotte D’Souza and Christie Ou contributing